In the first season of True Blood, we get a scene of the first date between virginal telepath Sookie Stackhouse and Bill Compton, the new Civil War era vampire in town whom everyone except Sookie assumes will kill and eat her. In the scene, Sookie’s Gran provides the guests in her parlour with little finger sandwiches, after which the courting couple head out for a walk through the woods to Bill’s house. When Bill kisses Sookie he becomes aroused but instead of trying to seduce the equally excited Sookie he immediately escorts her back home.
Sookie later determines that Bill’s association with his vile and despicable vampire friends Malcolm, Liam, and Diane make him an unsuitable suitor and breaks off their courtship for a brief period. Bill promptly pays a visit to the nest and threatens them with someone of a ‘higher authority’ than Eric if they come near Sookie again.
Of course this is not the end of Mr. Compton’s pursuit of the anachronistically innocent Sookie. Girls who have slept with vampires are being murdered all over town, and everyone knows Sookie has been consorting with a vampire, though it’s generally accepted amongst the residents of Bon Temps, Louisiana that the ‘deed’ has yet to be done. When Sookie’s brother is accused of the murders, her grandmother Adele urges her to use her gift of telepathy to clear his name. Bill Compton generously agrees to escort her to Fangtasia, the touristy but dangerous vampire bar in Shreveport owned by Louisiana’s vampire Sheriff Eric so she can gather information on just which vampires the dead girls were ‘familiar’ with.
Sookie’s grandmother Adele is soon shockingly murdered by the big bad wolf. Sookie kills the supposed killer Rene Lenier when he attacks her in the Bon Temps cemetary. Sookie’s telepathy assures her he was indeed the murderer of the dead girls as well as of her beloved Gran as she reads Rene’s jumbled, disjointed thoughts before she decapitates him with a shovel.
Sookie was publicly made a target when she lost her virginity to Vampire Bill and allowed him to feed on her the very night of Gran’s funeral, leaving visible fang marks on her neck. The murder mystery is laid to rest along with Rene.
Or is it?
Might Bud Dearborn, deceptively slow-talking, square dancing country boy human sheriff of Bon Temps revisit the murder of Adele at some point? After all, it’s only been a couple of months in True Blood time since the murder and new facts may eventually emerge. If Sheriff Bud thinks about it, he may wonder why Rene believed Sookie, a young woman whom everyone including Rene knew to be on a date with Sam Merlotte at Bill’s Daughters of the Glorious Dead presentation, would be home while believing the elderly Adele would be away from home late at night. What kind of sense does this make? Bud should reflect upon the victim profiles of the murdered women (young, sexually active with vampires) who were strangled while Adele was stabbed repeatedly with a knife. Doesn’t the sudden change in MO strike anyone else as strange? Bud, and the audience, needs to take to heart what he said at the scene of Gran’s bloody murder: “Vampires have been killing people and covering their tracks for a long time”. Andy never considered Bill a suspect while Bud did. Andy was also wrongly convinced Jason was the killer while Bud never believed it was him. Bud was right.
Will Sookie eventually remember Bill implanting a false memory via glamouring into the limo driver who tried to abduct her from the airport on behalf of The Fellowship of the Sun? Could she connect that with what she saw in Rene’s mind, and wonder? It might also occur to Sookie that she had not yet had sex with Vampire Bill when Rene failed to find her home that night from a date with Sam and killed her Gran instead. She should certainly consider the illuminating fact of Bill being capable of the cold-blooded murder of Uncle Bartlett, crippled pedophile though he may have been.
If Sookie searches her memory, she might find it strange that her grandmother was murdered the very night she rejected Bill in favor of Samby pointedly refusing to invite Bill out to coffee with them. After the murder, Sookie turned to the Alpha for comfort and protection.
Sookie may one day look back on how after her grandmothers brutal murder Bill effectively took over Gran’s role in her life-as parental figure, guardian, and protector. In many ways, just as the wolf disguised himself as Red Riding Hood’s grandmother, he has also taken on Gran’s persona-wise, patient, old-fashioned and courtly- a strikingly different Bill from the one we first met that night in Merlotte’s, and the one who sauntered confidently into the palace of the capricious vampire Queen Sophie-Anne.
How did Bill do it, on a practical level?
When Bill comes home to find Eric in his bathtub, he is carrying dry cleaning. His dry cleaning consists of a brown shirt and brown pants. Bill is wearing– a brown shirt and brown pants, exactly the shade of his dry cleaning. So we can assume Bill has at least duplicated one pair of clothing in his wardrobe. Why would he only do that for an innocuous BROWN pair of clothing? Might he have more than one pair of duplicate clothing?
Bill went nuts on the hearth with the pronged toaster just after Bud and Andy have spoken to him about Maudette and Dawn, and he flashes back to his making at the hands of Lorena and he is extremely ANGRY. Cut to Sookie later, maybe one scene? finding Gran. End of Ep.
Sookie was in danger of being stolen by Sam. She had broken up with Bill yet again and was on a date with Sam that very night, at the DGD meeting right in Bill’s FACE. Later, Sookie deliberately did not invite him to have coffee with her and Sam.
Bill had time (Sookie suggested he could get to his home from hers in one minute in the s2 finale) to wiz over to Gran’s, kill her within what? 30 seconds, with his vampire speed and anger?, and vampire back to his house, shower and change into duplicate clothing, and vampire back in time to come up behind Sookie mere moments after she’s found her Gran. Just in time to comfort her, and to threaten Sam when he comes in. Later, Sam found him upstairs standing by Sookie’s window. Why was he upstairs when everyone else was downstairs? When Sam left he opened the shutter and “examined” the cut in Sookie’s window screen.
Later, it was Bill who suggested to Bud and Andy that Gran was not the intended target. The implication is he told them, off camera, about the cut screen and everyone conveniently agreed that the killer was after Sookie.
Sookie later tells the Bunkie (?) Sheriff’s Deputy that vampires wouldn’t kill by strangulation.
Have we ever seen a vampire on TB resist a fresh, bloody corpse? Don’t you think if he HAD to Bill could in fact resist a bloody corpse, especially when he had to hurry out of there before Sookie got home?
Bill also claimed he heard Sookie come home from her date, but he didn’t hear the murderer.
Who is Bill Compton, really? I think we can now finally lay the perception of Bill as Saint to rest.


Bill’s not a saint, but he didn’t do it. The theory is interesting, but the books completely disprove it. It was definitely Rene of his own accord.
I’m not basing my analysis on the books. I’ve no idea what they suggest or do not suggest about Bill’s true nature. What I do know is that when I realized Bill was capable of heinous, cold-blooded murder for sport, on True Blood, all bets were off. (see my previous entry) When I saw that horrific scene of the murder of the Chicago couple, I realized I would have to reevaluate everything I thought I knew about Bill so I took a closer look at Gran’s murder. The clues are there and they all point straight at Bill.
Holy moly.
If even a quarter of this turns out to be fact, I will happily eat all the nasty words I’ve ever said about Alan Ball. And believe me, that is one big meal.
I can’t fault your reasoning. What makes me wonder though is when plot holes big enough to drive a truck through are already evident only two seasons in…when the finale is the total mess that it was….are they really this smart? I hope they are.
What you’ve presented here is factual evidence taken straight from the show, rather than emotion based conjecture. There is not alot of this sort of analysis around, and for that reason alone it deserves serious consideration.
I absolutely agree with your general premise that Bill is not what he seems. He is most definitely carefully concealing aspects of himself from everyone, and he will eventually be revealed for the duplicitous and flawed man that he is. I would believe this even without having read a single Sookie book, the clues are right there in the show.
I also suspect that Ball will take Bill to far worse extremes that Harris ever did.
Harris kept her two male leads a complicated mixture of good and bad, of flaw and conflict. She made the personality one relatively weak, and the other relatively controlled, and that was where their fundamental difference lay. It is the weak vs controlled dynamic that is still playing out between Bill and Eric 10 books down the line.
Ball has started out showing Eric far worse than he ever was in the books, and Bill is…well just short of saintly. He has chosen to start his story with the two of them placed at extremes. You can only assume that the purpose is to extract maximum shock value when he inverts everything at some point.
Great post, I really enjoyed it btw!
Thank you for your comment Sookieverseblog.
when the finale is the total mess that it was….are they really this smart? I hope they are.
Stay tuned. I have a theory on that one too, and YES, they are really that smart.
You can only assume that the purpose is to extract maximum shock value when he inverts everything at some point.
Oh absolutely. I have sneaking feeling Ball is aiming to ignite a firestorm, especially if he’s aware of the obsession that grips Bill fans.
I agree that Adele’s murder will be revisited on the show. Another thing that points to Bill as the murderer is the open front door. Too big a deal was made about the killer leaving the door open for it not to have significance.
It goes back to Dawn’s murder. When Sookie was being interviewed by Bud, she told him that Dawn’s door was open. He questioned her about whether it was just unlocked or open. Sookie said it was open, not just unlocked, and we saw Bud make a note of her response. Actually Sookie was in error because we saw her knocking on the closed screen door, opening it, and then pounding on the closed front door.
So why was so much time and detail spent on questioning Sookie about the position of the door in both of these murders, and what is the reason the writers made Sookie give Bud an obviously false answer? It was because, just like Book Bill, True Blood Bill broke into the sheriff’s office and read the report of Dawn’s murder. True Blood Bill put that information to use when he staged Gran’s murder.
(Hey lady, where have you been?)
Exactly. This is obviously an important point to consider. It’s clear Sookie was wrong, but BILL based his actions during the murder of Gran upon what he THOUGHT happened with Dawn, which will possibly catch up with him in the end. I remember he was very keen to know “HOW?” Dawn was murdered but Sookie never actually answered him.
While I love this analysis, and would LOVE to believe Ball is going to throw a monkey wrench into the Bill lover’s fantasies, there’s just one thing that throws it off. Sookie in the show (as well as the books) can’t be glamored. And of course, one could say, when we saw Bill try to do it, he wasn’t really trying at all for the purpose of throwing her off guard, but Eric has tried it as well, and it didn’t work for him either.
I would also LOVE to hear the speculation for the mess that was the last three episodes of Season Two. It might make me less cranky about Season 3! I threw a dinner party every week last season. This season coming up I am not considering it, as I feel the show got so bad, that I would prefer watching it alone so that I can fast forward the scenes I don’t care to see.
Hi Kathy, thanks for stopping by.
I’m not sure what you mean by Sookie can’t be glamoured? Of course this is true, but my analysis doesn’t depend on her being glamoured. I think Bill’s blood exerts an influence on her personality and this is why we saw such a drastic change in her from s1 to s2, but by ‘implanting a false memory’ I mean that I believe Bill implanted the false memory of killing Gran into RENE, so that if Sookie ever read his mind she would be assured he was the killer. This depends, of course, on Bill knowing Rene killed the other girls, but this isn’t out of the realm of possibility since usually Rene killed at night and Bill could have been skulking around.
Ohhhhhhh! I misread what you said. Okay. Plausable.
Wow good theories i hope that at least some of this is true…..at least the parts you wrote about the finale…that makes a lot of sense to tme…i mean sookie was running for like 20 seconds how could bill have gotten that huge amount of blood into sam and then sam have the energy and composure to shift into that rare bull and run all the way down to a point where he was ahead of Sookie and Maryanne???….it didnt make sense to me and i just dismissed it as me being biased but now that ive read your theories i think you are right.
Hi Ashley, and thanks.
I am pretty sure some of this is true. You’ve pointed out one of the most glaring errors in the finale that anyone should be able to see. AB isn’t dumb or incompetent, there has to be a reason for the plethora of mistakes, anomalies, ooc behavior, and contradictions.
It is bias when someone refuses to see something obvious simply because it goes against what they want to believe. You questioned what you saw but dismissed it because you acknowledge you
might be biased. This is a good thing, and honest, and the only way anyone should test a theory or hunch. Next time don’t be so quick to dismiss your intuition. The folks who want to believe the scenes aren’t questioning anything, much less their pre-conceived beliefs.
Love the theories!!! Moreover, I love the way you are separating the books from the show! I had not ever even thought about the “change in MO” in the death of Gran. Now, completely contradicting myself…even in the book Sookie makes a HUGE deal about how Rene will not pursue his attempt to kill her until he locates his garrote. He holds on to her and searches the ground for the ligature but he could have just choked her with his hands. A man who won’t deviate even THAT far from his MO isn’t likely to suddenly veer off and stab someone to death multiple times!
Great stuff!
Exactly! And remember, Sookie told the deputy in Bunkie (sp?) that if a vampire was going to murder someone he would not strangle them! Well, Gran certainly wasn’t strangled, was she? Rene was a methodical, as opposed to disorganized, serial killer with a strict MO and a definitive victim profile. Nothing about Grans murder fit his usual pattern.
Hang on to your hat because I think Bill keeps ‘souvenirs’ and either Jessica or Sookie will find them in his cubby hole while he’s gone. Possibly Tina’s missing head, the cops gun, something of Uncle Bartlett’s, and something of Gran’s.
I bet it’s going to be Gran’s corsage from the Glorious Dead meeting, and don’t forget Mack’s ring that practically got more screen time than Hadley and Denise’s bag.
OMG you’re right, I totally forgot about Mack’s ring. There was something else we discussed too but it has slipped my mind. Did we think he has Amy’s bag for some reason?
Well, I think he’s got a piece of Uncle Barlett, maybe a finger or perhaps another digit that Sookie would have liked to remove herself. The camera didn’t lovingly linger on any of Denise’s accessories like it did twice on Mack’s ring, but she was carrying a giant bag, so I figure that’s what will be found at Bill’s and, when it’s opened, all of his other souvenirs will come spilling out.
Ah yes, I knew it had something to do with one or another of the ‘big ol’ bag(s) of crazy’ lol.
A lot of the commenters do have a point though–TB can’t wait too long to reveal some of this stuff or people are going to get bored of it all. The ‘reality’ of these scenes are theoretically much better television than Bill’s stultefyingly boring faulty pov’s. And the ‘reality’ of Bill coming at us full bore will also be much more exciting than the ‘human act’ he puts on.
HOLY CRAP! Sunnynala, you just gave me a feast for thought.
Glad you liked it.
And may I remind you?
Stephen Moyer: “You will not fucking believe what they are doing to my character”.
My Goodness!
I headed over here on a recommendation from the sookieverse blog, and while at times I think you may be over-analyzing or giving AB more credit than he is due, this has all been fascinating reading! I love the concepts of alter egos that you brought up, with the Bill/Rene and Eric/Jason parallels! You have really put a ton of thought into this.
I’m trying really hard to separate the show from the books, and if AB really sets Bill up as Gran’s killer I will finally be able to separate them completely and will have tons more respect for AB! That scene with him killing those people and taking their house made me realize that AB might have some great stuff in store for Bill (great as in interesting, not great as in good morals haha) and your points about the differences in the murders are spot on!
Thank you Katie!
I’ve said it all along: AB is making Bill a MILLION times worse than book Bill. I believe in AB! lol
Did you ever remember this scene from the Season 1 Episode 9? It’s starts out with something that made me laugh but the part I want you to see (and you probably already know about it) is toward the end around 2:17. Sookie closes her eyes and grabs Bill’s hand as she turns over to sleep. I think she just read his mind. Do you?
I agree Chris, I think this is exactly what happened. The angle was too odd to be her memory of the scene. The view directly into Gran’s face seems to be from the floor and only a hovering vampire could have done that–or left no footprints in the pool of blood surrounding her.
Wow Chris that is an awesome clip, I never thought about it that way. That even more than Sunny’s awesome ideas solidifies that it WAS Bill who killed Gran.
Pingback: The Ancient Pythoness » Blog Archive » Hmmmm…
Pingback: The Ancient Pythoness » Blog Archive » Frenzied
Pingback: Through the Looking Glass | True Blood Underground
Pingback: Sookie Stackhouse, mind control victim | True Blood Underground
WOW… what you are saying in all of these posts makes so much sense! I didn’t even think about it before. I thought bill was simply a tortured soul but you are connecting all the dots for me. I would be so happy if this was what alan ball was really doing. A lofty mind control experiment disguised as a show about vampire porn. Especially with the last episode “I smell a rat” its becoming increasingly clear that Bill is a lying sack of shit, but if what you are saying is true then he is so much more than that. Alan ball is a smart smart man, I wouldn’t put it past him.
Hi gina, welcome!
Indeed AB IS a smart smart man! He is my hero, lol.
Bill is a tortured soul in the same sense as a hungry pig! He is greedy and corrupt and utterly lacking in compassion and decency. It’s all there on the screen, and as you say, all one needs to do is connect the dots.
oh how i hope this theory of urs is proven right! i’d like to see a bill fan spin this to bills advantage!
Also as I was rewatching that clip that Chris brought I noticed that when Sookie said “I just can’t get the image of her face out of my mind.” That Bill immediately brings up Tina even though that wouldn’t make sense. It’s almost like he is trying to get her not to think about Gran’s murder too closely.
Welcome gini!
This, plus he’s so lacking in empathy he would assume she’s grieving more for her cat than for her grandmother.
Pingback: Smoking Mirrors « True Blood Underground
Pingback: “It’s Just True Blood” « True Blood Underground